Getty Images

Skims $148 Advent Calendar Backlash Tests Whether Store Credit Can Win Back Angry Customers

George Ellis
8 Min Read

A $148 Skims advent calendar filled with keychains, bobby pins, scrunchies and hair ties instead of the brand’s signature bodysuits and loungewear has sparked a wave of customer outrage on social media, leaving the Kim Kardashian-backed company trying to contain the fallout.

Content creator Kayla Ryan summed up the mood in a TikTok video this week, calling it “the worst advent calendar I’ve ever opened” and comparing the contents to items from a dollar store. Her video was one of countless posts criticising the 12-day calendar, which many buyers felt did not match Skims’ premium positioning or the price tag.

Skims’ response

In response, Skims personally contacted every customer who purchased the calendar and offered a choice between a full refund or store credit, according to a spokesperson. The catch, outlined in the email sent to buyers, is that a cash refund requires returning the calendar, while those who accept store credit can keep it.

That detail fuelled speculation that the company had intentionally angered customers as a marketing ploy. Jessica Tillery, a senior vice president at Allison Worldwide, argued in a LinkedIn post that the arrangement was calculated: every dollar spent above the $148 credit becomes new revenue, and every shopper who returns to use the credit counts as a repeat purchaser.

Do shoppers really overspend store credit?

Research suggests store credit can indeed encourage additional spending. Blackhawk Network’s 2026 research found that nearly 60% of shoppers say they would spend beyond a gift card’s balance, paying an average of $73 more. A 2025 study by Northwestern Kellogg School of Management lecturer Ata Jami also found that shoppers are more likely to spend money they receive from returns, and tend to splurge with it because it feels less painful than spending cash.

But some marketers and consumer researchers say the stunt theory does not hold up. Chris Ribeiro, founder of Starlight Analytics and a marketing professor at Rutgers Business School, told Fortune that alienating core customers is poor marketing regardless of the short-term accounting.

“This store credit is the customer’s own $148, following a poor experience,” Ribeiro said.

Sentiment turns sharply negative

Starlight Analytics tracked U.S. social posts about Skims and the calendar between 2 November and 11 November and found negative posts outnumbered positive ones by roughly eight to one. As the total volume of posts declined, negativity became even more dominant, rising from 13% of mentions on 6 November to 76% on 11 November.

Nataly Kelly, chief marketing officer at consumer insights platform Zappi, said the problem likely began before the unboxing videos went viral. "This is a product that never got checked against what shoppers think $148 should buy," she told Fortune. Zappi's research indicates only one in 10 consumers sticks solely to name brands, suggesting brand loyalty alone cannot carry a weak offer.

The longer-term risk

Ben Metcalfe, founder of BlackFire Marketing, told Fortune that store credit is "smarter than just a refund" because it brings shoppers back. Still, plenty of that money goes unused: a 2024 Bankrate survey found that roughly 43% of Americans hold leftover gift cards, vouchers or store credit, with an average of $244 unspent.

Metcalfe expects Skims to absorb the direct cost of the calendar controversy, but warned that the lasting damage may be to customer trust. "Negative attention can boost awareness, but awareness isn't loyalty," he said. "Brands can survive a single viral mistake, but they struggle when their customers start to see a pattern."

Share This Article